Best Pizza Spots in Fort Myers (NY-Style & Brick Oven)

Fort Myers pizza runs from hand-tossed New York pies downtown to brick-oven pizza on McGregor and a 36-hour dough on Six Mile Cypress.

Highlights

• Downtown House of Pizza – Hand-tossed New York-style pizza in downtown Fort Myers
• Fat Tony’s Pizza – 36-hour dough pizza on Six Mile Cypress, Fort Myers
• Tony’s N.Y. Pizza – Fold-in-half NY slices at The Forum
• McGregor Pizza Company – McGregor Blvd – Brick-oven pizza on historic McGregor Blvd

All listings

• General
• Real Estate
• Restaurant

What are you looking for?

Location

Category CategoryAnimal Shelter / Pet AdoptionAuto DealerAuto DetailingAuto PartsAuto RepairBankBreweryBuffetCafeCasual DiningChildcareCivic / Fire DistrictContemporary CasualDentistDog Daycare / BoardingElectricianFamily StyleFast CasualFast FoodFine DiningGeneral StoreGym / FitnessHandymanHardware StoreHouse CleaningHVACIce CreamLawn CareMoving / HaulingMuseum / AttractionPest ControlPharmacyPlumbingPool ServicePool Supplies/ServicePressure WashingRestaurant - AmericanRestaurant - AsianRestaurant - Brazilian SteakhouseRestaurant - BreakfastRestaurant - ItalianRestaurant - KoreanRestaurant - Korean/SteakhouseRestaurant - MexicanRestaurant - PizzaRestaurant - SouthernRestaurant - WingsRestaurant / MarketRestaurant Seafood/ SteakhouseRoofingRV ParkUrgent CareVeterinarian

4 Items Found

Sort By

A to Z (title) Z to A (title) Latest listings Oldest listings Popular listings Random listings

Filter Show Map

Fat Tony’s Pizza

0.0 0 reviews

• 9390 Six Mile Cypress Pkwy, Suite 3, Fort Myers, FL 33966
• (239) 990-6967
• October 18, 2026

Downtown House of Pizza

0.0 0 reviews

• 1520 Hendry St, Fort Myers, FL 33901
• (239) 337-3467
• October 18, 2026

Tony’s N.Y. Pizza

0.0 0 reviews

• 3398 Forum Blvd #101, Fort Myers, FL 33905, United States
• +12399317991
• March 9, 2026

McGregor Pizza Company – McGregor Blvd

0.0 0 reviews

• 4600 McGregor Blvd Ste B, Fort Myers, FL, United States, 33901
• (239) 939-1148
• March 9, 2026

Explore more

Areas: San Carlos Park · Estero · South Fort Myers · Downtown Fort Myers · Fort Myers Beach

Categories: Korean food · Restaurants · Pizza · Seafood · AC & HVAC · Dentists · Vets & pet services · Home services · Things to do

Own a business listed here? Email business@yaboyrocklee.com with corrections. Hours and details come from each business’s own website; please call ahead to confirm.