Best Pizza in Fort Myers: Local Picks + Video Reviews
Downtown House of Pizza has drawn the most creator videos of any pizza place on Local Atlas HQ, so it leads this list. Picks are based on businesses we have verified on Local Atlas HQ and on public creator videos; no business paid for placement.
1. Downtown House of Pizza
Hand-tossed New York-style pizza in downtown Fort Myers. Hours, phone & map →
Seen on YouTube
Video by The Fat Cowboy on YouTube. Embedded via YouTube; not produced by Local Atlas HQ.
Video by The Tourist Trap on YouTube. Embedded via YouTube; not produced by Local Atlas HQ.
Video by BB's Adventures on YouTube. Embedded via YouTube; not produced by Local Atlas HQ.
Video by Naples Daily News on YouTube. Embedded via YouTube; not produced by Local Atlas HQ.
2. Fat Tony’s Pizza
36-hour dough pizza on Six Mile Cypress, Fort Myers. Hours, phone & map →
3. Tony’s N.Y. Pizza
Fold-in-half NY slices at The Forum. Hours, phone & map →
4. McGregor Pizza Company – McGregor Blvd
Brick-oven pizza on historic McGregor Blvd. Hours, phone & map →
Explore more
Areas: San Carlos Park · Estero · South Fort Myers · Downtown Fort Myers · Fort Myers Beach
Categories: Korean food · Restaurants · Pizza · Seafood · AC & HVAC · Dentists · Vets & pet services · Home services · Things to do
Own a business listed here? Email business@yaboyrocklee.com with corrections. Hours and details come from each business’s own website; please call ahead to confirm.